Book a call
← All case studies
Case study · E-commerce · SEO · Industry

Two brands in one group,
taking customers from each other.

An industrial group runs two B2B web shops for standard parts and operating parts, on the same shop system and with a similar product range. We put both shops side by side: GA4, Google Ads, SISTRIX and Search Console, each comparing 92 days with the previous 92 days. The result: two very different problems and one shared lever that only the group itself can pull.

72 %of shared keywords are won by one brand against the other
15–20 %of Google Ads auctions: the brands bid against each other
59 %less organic revenue for brand B year on year
p = 0.006the conversion decline at brand A is statistically robust
Two findings

The same technology, very different problems.

Brand A has a conversion problem. Almost 9 % more visitors came, but the conversion rate fell from 1.56 % to 1.42 %. Organic search brings just under half of the visits, but less than a fifth of the purchases.

Brand B has a reach problem. Those who come, buy: the conversion rate is stable, and revenue even rose by 17 % thanks to larger baskets. But visibility in Google is around 70 % below its peak, and paid clicks are increasingly replacing free ones.

GA4Channels, purchases, baskets and product data for both shops.
Google AdsAuction data: how often the brands bid against each other.
SISTRIX & Search ConsoleVisibility, shared keywords, click-through rates on the brand name.
The key findings

What the data showed.

338
01 · Group

The brands compete in search.

Both shops rank for 338 keywords. Brand A is ahead in 72 % of cases, brand B leads for standards and DIN parts. Google spreads the rankings across two similar domains instead of clearly preferring one.

17 %
02 · Brand name

A trading partner ranks for the brand's own name.

When searching for brand B's name, partner sites with the same items appeared in positions 2 to 6. The click-through rate on the brand's own result fell from 64.5 % to 17 %.

+86 %
03 · Paid instead of organic

Paid clicks replace free ones.

While brand B's organic visits fell by a third, paid sessions rose by 86 %. If the ad sits above the brand's own result, the purchase is attributed to paid and organic looks weaker than it is.

9 %
04 · Basket

One product family stays in the basket.

For most families, a third to a half of the items in the basket are actually bought. For one family, only 9 %. To check: minimum order quantity, packaging unit, price display.

43 %
05 · Tracking

Almost half the revenue without items.

At brand A, 43 % of revenue was not assigned to any product, and Google Ads reported 40 % more purchases while GA4 showed only 9 % more. Before budgets are steered by product, the tracking has to be right. Because both shops run on the same system, one developer ticket fixes the problem for both brands.

Conversion rate by channel

Where each brand is stronger.

Purchases divided by sessions, by channel. Brand A is ahead only in paid search. Organic is the weak spot for both. Hatched: clearly below the other brand.

Direct
Paid Search
Performance Max
Email
Referral
Organic Search
AI assistants

GA4, 92 days. Bayesian comparison of the channels: for brand B, direct is ahead of paid search with a probability of over 99.9 %; for brand A, there is no clear winner.

Method

Robust, not just striking.

With two shops with similar figures, something quickly looks “striking”. We tested every statement before it went onto a slide.

z-test on conversionIs the decline from 1.56 % to 1.42 % real or chance? Real.p = 0.006
Bayesian channel comparisonHow likely is it that one channel is better than another?P(Direct > Paid) > 99.9 %
Elasticity from 66 working daysHow much do purchases rise when organic visits rise? For brand B, almost one to one.+10 % sessions ≈ +11 % purchases
Keyword overlapShared rankings from 100 searches a month, with the stronger brand for each term.338 keywords · 72 % : 28 %
Time series comparisonVisibility drop compared against updates, relaunches and range changes.Autumn 2024
Technical comparisonHTML size, rendered links, structured data, hreflang: the same weaknesses in both, so technology does not explain the loss.2.0 MB : 2.7 MB
What happens now

Four decisions for the group.

MeasureWhoWhy
Separate the brands in Google AdsGroupThe brands are driving up each other's click prices.
Divide topics: standard parts here, operating parts thereBoth brandsEach brand has its own strengths. Clear responsibility instead of two half rankings.
Clarify partners ranking for the brand nameBrand BThe brand should come first when people search for it.
Fix basket and trackingBoth shopsOne ticket, one shop system, two brands with reliable product data.

For reasons of confidentiality, we do not name the group or its brands and do not show absolute revenue.

Similar project?

Several brands, one plan?

Tell us in 30 minutes where you stand, or send a short message. We will tell you honestly whether and how we can help.

Armin Sanjari
Armin SanjariFounder & CEO · Your contact

Prefer to call? +49 711 500 908-17

Book a 30-minute call →
or send a short message

Armin replies personallyWithin 24 hours on working days · no obligation · no sales pressure

Request a free SEO check →

Book a 30-minute call

Open at Calendly ↗ · Send a message instead · Privacy settings